WWhen the conversation turns to Argentina’s stars in MLS, the spotlight usually falls on global names. But in 2026, another player is forcing its way into the discussion, and it’s becoming harder to ignore.
Nicolas Fernandez-Merkau has emerged as one of the most in-form players in Major League Soccer, but his recent performance begs the obvious question: Is he the league’s most dormant star? Through nine games against New York City FC, Fernandez-Merkau is summarizing Landon Donovan’s MVP-caliber campaign.
His most recent statement came at Yankee Stadium, where he scored twice in the chaos of a 4-4 tie with FC Cincinnati. These two goals took his total for the season to eight points, moving him one point behind Golden Boot leader Petar Moussa. Fernandes has already surpassed MLS top scorers such as Sam Surridge and Lionel Messi in the early stages of the Golden Boot race.
His influence goes beyond just a streak.
With his latest goal, Fernandez-Merkau becomes the fourth player in NYCFC history to score at least 10 goals in the first 20 games of the regular season, the first since Ebert in 2019. This is one of the strongest starts in the club’s history, especially for a player who only joined as a designated player midway through last season.
Ramin Yamal shows leadership beyond his years after painful departure
In last year’s MLS Cup Playoffs, Nicholas had key performances that helped eliminate Charlotte FC and the Philadelphia Union. That ability to show up at key moments carries over into 2026, where he takes on an even bigger role.
With striker Alonso Martinez sidelined with a torn ACL, Fernandes took on the No. 9 role to keep the team competitive. His versatility, moving from a supporting role to being a leading scorer, is crucial for a team currently in the middle of the Eastern Conference.
Why doesn’t he get more attention?
New York FC doesn’t always get the same national attention as other MLS clubs, and Fernandes doesn’t have the same global profile as some of the league’s biggest names. But statistically and stylistically, he produces at a level that demands recognition.
There is also a broader context in MLS where star power is often tied to reputation as well as performance. Players like Messi naturally hog the headlines, so other players, even those who perform at an elite level, don’t get the attention they deserve.
If Nicholas continues at this pace, he’ll be more than just in the MVP conversation. His goal-scoring consistency, ability to score in key moments, and expanded role in the team’s attack all point to a player reaching his prime in real time. And so far, the label is spot on.
